From a distance, a link page for a shop and a link page for a newsletter look like the same object. Photo at the top, name, a short line of text, then a stack of buttons going down the screen. Same furniture.
They are doing opposite work.
A shop page is an index. Someone arrives already knowing roughly what they want, or at least which shelf they want to stand in front of. Four product links, a sizing guide, a returns page, the TikTok that made them curious. The page succeeds by being a decent menu and then getting out of the way. More options is not automatically worse. If someone wanted the green one and the green one is listed, good.
A newsletter page is not a menu. There is one thing to do on it, and everything else exists to help someone decide whether to do that thing. Which means every extra button is not a bonus option. It is a small invitation to leave.
Hold two pages next to each other
First page. Someone sells phone cases through TikTok Shop. Their link page has six product links, a link to the Shopify store, a discount code, an Instagram icon, a Pinterest icon, a link to a review video, and a shipping FAQ. Crowded, slightly chaotic, basically fine. Visitors arrive with different intentions and the page catches most of them. Nobody feels tricked by a menu.
Second page. Someone writes a weekly email about one neighbourhood. What opened, what closed, which street is dug up until April, three things happening at the weekend. Four minutes to read, Thursday mornings. If that page has six buttons, it has failed before anyone reads a word, because the reader now has to work out which of the six is the newsletter and why the other five are there. The page has made its own offer look like one item on a trolley.
The local newsletter has an advantage the phone case seller does not, and it is worth naming. Its value is extremely easy to describe. You can say exactly what arrives and exactly when. The phone case seller cannot summarise a shop in one sentence without losing most of it. So use the advantage. Put the sentence on the page and let it carry the weight.
The promise is the page
Most newsletter pages fail at the top, in the one line of bio text, and then spend the rest of the page trying to recover.
The failing version sounds like a community. Curated local insights for people who love this city. Nothing in that sentence tells anyone what will land in their inbox, how often, or how long it takes to read. It is a mood. Moods do not get typed into an email field.
The working version is boring and specific. Every Thursday morning: what is on this weekend in the neighbourhood, plus anything that changed. About four minutes. Now the reader can do arithmetic. Fifty two emails a year, four minutes each, about the area they live in. They can decide. Some will decide no, and that is a good outcome, because an address from someone who did not want it is a future unsubscribe with extra steps.
Frequency belongs in the promise, not hidden in a footer. It is the thing people are actually pricing. The fear is not that your writing is bad, it is that signing up means an unknown number of interruptions forever. Naming the number closes that gap for free. I have written about the shape of that request in the first email signup that does not feel like a trap, and most of it applies here, just with the box moved to a page of its own.
If you want the general version of the argument, not newsletter specific, there is what your link page should say before anyone clicks.
One sample, not an archive
The second thing a newsletter page needs is evidence, and the cheapest honest evidence is one past issue.
Not an archive. An archive is a list of forty titles that nobody reads, and if you have published twice it is a list of two titles that quietly reports how new you are. One link, labelled as what it is. Read last Thursday's issue. The reader clicks, skims for eight seconds, and learns the three things no description can tell them: how long it actually is, whether the tone suits them, and whether it is written by a person or by a content calendar.
If you have not published anything yet, write one issue and publish it anyway. Not a sample pack, not a teaser. A real issue, with real items in it, the length you intend to keep. Then link to it. A newsletter with one issue and one honest promise is in better shape than a newsletter with a waiting list page and nothing behind it.
One sample also saves you from describing your newsletter in adjectives. You do not need to claim it is useful. You can just let someone look at it.
What not to add, which is most things
This goes wrong gradually, not all at once.
You add a tip jar, because someone suggested it. Then a link to the merch you have not made yet. Then the Instagram icon, the TikTok icon, the Threads icon, the one for the account you abandoned in 2023. Then the other project, the podcast you record sometimes, a Notion template, an affiliate code for the coffee you like. None of these decisions is wrong on its own. Each one is a reasonable five second thought. Stacked up, they turn a page with one clear request into a car boot sale, and the signup, which is the only thing you actually wanted, is now the fourth button down and visually identical to the affiliate code.
A useful test. For each item, ask what you would rather the reader did, click that, or sign up. If the answer is sign up, the item is costing you something. Keep it only if it makes the signup more credible, which a sample issue does, and which a Pinterest icon does not.
Two or three social icons at the bottom are fine. They are small, they do not compete, and they let someone check you are a real person. A second full width button labelled Shop my merch is not fine, because it is the same size and shape as the thing you want them to do.
Relay is partly guilty here, and I would rather say it than not. Every plan has unlimited links, including the free one. That is a real feature, and it is also a standing invitation to misbehave. Nothing in the editor will stop you adding a fourteenth button. The restraint has to come from you, and on a newsletter page restraint is close to the whole job.
Building the thing, and what it costs
So what does this look like in practice.
On Relay you claim a name, build a draft, and publish when you are ready. Claiming the name does not publish anything, which matters if you want to sit on a half finished page for a week. The free plan has no card and no time limit: your photo and bio, unlimited links, social icons, five themes, and headings and dividers, which are the two bits that let you separate the signup from everything underneath it visually rather than just hoping. There is also a QR code and a story sized share image. Both earn their keep for a local newsletter in particular, since a QR on a poster in a café window is a better use of a wall than a handle people have to type. More on that in when a QR code is better than another social link.
The honest limit on free: email capture is a Pro feature. On the free plan your signup is a link out to whatever hosted form your email tool gives you, Buttondown or Beehiiv or Mailchimp or Substack. That works, and plenty of pages run that way, but it is one extra hop and you will lose a few people on it. Pro is $49.99 a year or $8 a month plus applicable VAT, and it adds inline email capture, all 59 themes, more fonts, custom colours, background image, per-link images, scheduled links, inline players, Insights with page views, card opens, visitor countries, devices, traffic sources and statistics exports, and removal of the Relay badge. Insights is the part I would actually use here, because it tells you whether people are arriving and ignoring the page, or not arriving at all, and those two problems need different fixes.
A shape you can copy
For the weekly local newsletter, in order: photo, name, the promise with the day and the reading time in it, then the signup, then a divider, then one link to last week's issue, then two social icons at the bottom. That is the page. Seven elements, one of which is a line of empty space.
It will look underbuilt next to a shop page, and it should. The shop page answers many questions from many people. Yours answers one question from one person, who is standing in a doorway with their thumb hovering, deciding whether four minutes a week is a fair trade.
If you post irregularly, or you are building this before there is much of an audience to build it for, a link page for people who do not post every day covers the version where the page has to work without a steady feed behind it.
And if you want to try the layout, start a draft and leave it unpublished until the promise reads properly. The page takes twenty minutes. The sentence at the top takes longer, and it decides everything else.